TITLE: Hoping Against Hope

AUTHOR: John D. Caputo

PUBLISHER: Fortress Press, October 1, 2015 (224 pages)

Hoping Against Hope: Confessions of a Postmodern Pilgrim is the latest from the pen of John D. Caputo, Thomas J. Watson Professor of Religion Emeritus (Syracuse University). Only this work is slightly different from what you have read from him in past publications. As the subtitle eludes to this is a confession or a personal narrative where Caputo articulates his fascinating journey or pilgrimage through his life of faith.

Almost immediately one can find expressions in this book with which they whole heartily disagree and without hesitation write the book off. For this reader I would encourage you to take down your hasty judgements momentarily. I too came to this book with reservations about Caputo’s religion and philosophy which I haven’t changed. However, this is a personal narrative that covers similar difficulties that we have all experienced in life’s journey.

To communicate the broad range of experience Caputo introduces very early in the book three separate characters that represent himself through different phases of his life. For example, Caputo introduces us to “Jackie” which is his younger self. Jackie is a young impressionable alter boy who through out the book represents the timidness and piety of  pre-Vatican II American Catholicism. As a former Catholic (post-Vatican II) I was the recipient of the vestiges of this form of Catholicism giving me the ability to resonate with Jackie.

We are also introduced to “Brother Paul”. Brother Paul represents a more mature Caputo but not fully culminated into the final character the “Professor”. Brother Paul was zealous for the Catholic faith. He has grown spiritually and in knowledge ready to take down what is contrary to the teachings of the Church but not quite as mature in these respects as the “Professor”. The Professor represents his current self who has reached a level of maturity giving him the ability to think independently invoking resources from theology and philosophy to cultivate himself and those he instructs.  The outcome is a “religion without why”.

Typically what we find in religion is something counter intuitive to the “religion without why”. In most cases the bottom line motivation for religious practices is fear of punishment and hope for reward. The Professor scoffs at such a crude motivation. For him understanding God comes in the form of a type of praxis where to ask the question “why” is an absurdity. Why do we practice mercy, compassion, love, etc. because that is what we do and to invoke fear of punishment and hope for reward is to observe a crewed form or religion. At certain points the Professor refers to this as the “nihilism of grace.”


As I stated above, this is a personal confession. As such we are looking deep within the experiences and thoughts which culminated into the Professor.  Many of us have had similar experiences / thoughts that have either been left responseless or have convinced ourselves of easy answers so that we can keep our pre-commitment to our religion of choice. Not the case with Caputo. For that reason alone I see this as an important book. The fact that the experiences of the Professor have brought him to a Post-Modern interpretation of religion also makes this book important.

However, I will also say by invoking a Post-Modern narrative we are brought no closer to a religion without illusion. In fact what we are tacitly doing is invoking the preformed thoughts that already exist in our thinking or what Caputo refers to as the “religion without why”. The fear that I find in Caputo is that a religion with a why necessarily imposes a system of merit. However that isn’t necessarily the case.  As one example and I will leave this alone, in Christianity the good works that we do are not solely done for fear of punishment and hope of reward but out of a genuine gratitude for the grace, mercy, and peace we experience with God.

This is just one counter point. Like I said above I found Caputo’s book to be a very interesting read. I enjoyed and appreciated his dialogue with Jaques Derrida and Jean ean-François Lyotard. Caputo is an outstanding writer and thinker. In spite of my critique I still believe there is plenty to glean from him.

RATING: 4 Stars



1 Comment

Filed under God

One response to “

  1. Pingback: Hoping Against Hope Blog Tour | Cross Focused Reviews

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.